The Chamberlain Files | Homepage
Does Birmingham have no monumental non-royal women?

Does Birmingham have no monumental non-royal women?

🕔27.Apr 2017

An early General Election prediction: fewer women than men will vote on June 8th – as in every recent General Election. And in striking contrast to the US, where in every Presidential election since 1980 – long before there was a woman candidate to support – literally millions more women have voted than men, writes Chris Game

One small part of the reason, I personally like to think, might just have something to do with there being considerably more American women achievers visibly commemorated in public outdoor sculptures. In actual numbers, obviously, but also proportionately – though comparisons are complicated by the main achievement of most of our memorialised women being simply to have been born royal.

This was one of the problems that confronted Caroline Criado-Perez, the journalist and feminist campaigner chiefly responsible for our new polymer £10 notes, as well as our shiny new £2 coins, featuring the head of Jane Austen, rather than another already well celebrated chap.

It’s one of many sad features of our times that women’s reward for campaigning successfully on such issues tends to be large quantities of vile social media abuse, and Criado-Perez was no exception. Undeterred, though, she turned to ‘sexing’ the 925 statues on the Public Monuments and Sculpture Association’s database.

Initially, and excluding animals and the gender-ambiguous, there seemed an almost encouraging number of female-looking figures: 253 out of 885. Approaching one in three, which is more than, say, women high court judges or university professors.

However, once C-P discounted the 100-plus mythical and allegorical creations, the Virgin Marys, anonymous nudes, and the odd mermaid, there remained just 71 historical women and 517 historical men. Down to one in eight.

Moreover, only 19 of the men are royals, but 46 women, including, as if in some surreal Monty Python sketch, 29 Queen Victorias.  So, of all Britain’s statues, Criado-Perez reckoned that historical, non-royal women comprise just 2.7 per cent – encouraging as an annual growth rate, but hardly as a contribution to gender equality.

Hence her second successful campaign – a petition to London Mayor, Sadiq Khan, for “a statue of a suffragette in Parliament Square to mark [in 2018] 100 years of female suffrage”.

And, as significantly, to break the Square’s monopoly of 11 notable statesmen, doubtless worthy of statuary honour, but several – Jan Smuts (1920s South African PM), Abraham Lincoln, even Nelson Mandela – with less obvious claim for commemoration at the heart of UK democracy than leaders of the long battle for women’s suffrage.

Interestingly, despite her petition’s actual wording, Criado-Perez’s own favoured and eventually chosen nominee was Millicent Fawcett, a tireless feminist campaigner, founder and leader of the National Union of Women’s Suffrage Societies, and therefore, back when these distinctions really mattered, a non-violent suffragist.

Definitely not, in short, a militant, hunger-striking suffragette – the term associated with Emmeline Pankhurst’s radical Women’s Social and Political Union, who anyway already has a statue nearby in Victoria Tower Gardens.

The widely supported campaign was eventually awarded a Government grant from next year’s £5 million centenary fund. Whereupon the Mayor’s Suffrage Statue Commission selected as sculptor Birmingham-born conceptual artist, Gillian Wearing.

It was an interesting choice, for most of Wearing’s best-known work, including her Turner Prize-winning ‘60 Minutes Silence’, has been in photography and video. Until, of course, her 2014 bronze sculpture of ‘A Real Birmingham Family’ (ARBF) in front of our city’s new library (main picture), the ‘contemporary style’ of which doubtless helped her case.

It also sits well with Criado-Perez’s concern at the sculptural dearth of real non-royal women. For, by my count, Roma and Emma Jones, the two ARBF sisters depicted with their two – or two and a half – children, could well be the only two ‘real’ non-royal women to be found among Birmingham’s outdoor sculptures.

Even if wrong, that I can even seriously suggest it represents a pretty sad state of affairs, and I am always slightly embarrassed by my own workplace, the University of Birmingham’s Edgbaston campus, being a prime contributor.

The University does possess a striking work by one of Britain’s greatest sculptors, Sir Jacob Epstein – a portrait bust of Obstetrics Professor and medical pioneer, Dame Hilda Lloyd. But unfortunately, like a character in a Brontë novel, she’s mostly kept indoors in the Medical School, accessible only by prior appointment.

Far more visible – fronting its most important building and seen, if not comprehendingly, by all students in their first days in the University – is Henry Pegram’s ‘Pantheon of the Immortals’ frieze of nine life-size stone statues representing founder Joseph Chamberlain’s vision for his new institution for the study of the universality of human knowledge.

 

 

 

 

Their dress and hairstyles mean that at a quick glance several could easily pass as women – Beethoven, Virgil, Faraday, Newton certainly, maybe even Shakespeare. But all, of course, are indisputably Great Men.

If several are apparently looking down, it’s possibly at the only woman around – Bernard Sindall’s perky bronze ‘Girl in a Hat’. Yes, that’s it: just a hat, even in winter.

Odd, but she’s not alone. In the middle of James Watt Queensway there’s Robert Thomas’s ‘Hebe’, the Greek goddess of youth, seemingly panning optimistically for gold, and, in the Cadbury Factory grounds in Bournville, ‘Terpsichore’, the muse of dance, both activities evidently necessitating complete nudity.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Incidentally, Terpsi’s creator, William Bloye, easily Birmingham’s most widely displayed civic sculptor, was also responsible for the ‘Huntsman and Dog’ pub sign of my near-local, The Green Man in Harborne. And partly too for ‘Queen Victoria’ in Victoria Square – though, perhaps thankfully given Bloye’s creative predilection for undraped women, for its 1951 bronze recasting, not the 1901 original.

Manchester councillor, Andrew Simcock, reckoned his city’s Queen Victoria was similarly its only non-royal statue. So he launched a WoManchester campaign, raising enough to commission its own Emmeline Pankhurst.

But there are loads of other recent, and more original, examples: Sheffield’s wartime munitions factory workers, ‘Women of Steel’; Carlisle’s biscuit factory ‘Cracker Packers’; 1930s aviator Amy Johnson in both Hull and Herne Bay, Kent; Victoria Wood, as Dinnerlady Bren, in Bury.

Which suggests it’s time, surely, for Birmingham too to address our own bronze ceiling?

Similar Articles

Council: it’s not all rubbish

Council: it’s not all rubbish 0

Yesterday's announcement of a suspension of industrial action by Unite the union in the dispute

It’s official – the West Midlands has the cheapo mayor

It’s official – the West Midlands has the cheapo mayor 0

Assiduous Files followers may possibly recall the meticulous approach adopted to the determination of the

Combined Authority logos – do they do it for you?

Combined Authority logos – do they do it for you? 1

With branding of the West Midlands, as ever, under discussion and the Midlands Engine currently

Simon: Street has failed and made no difference

Simon: Street has failed and made no difference 1

Andy Street won the mayoral election by under 4,000 more votes than main rival Siôn

What should the Mayor do on skills & housing?

What should the Mayor do on skills & housing? 0

Andy Street says that negotiations have started over Devolution Deal II and that skills and

About Author

Chamberlain Files Weekly

Don't miss a thing! Sign up for our free weekly summary of the Chamberlain Files from RJF Public Affairs.
* = required field

powered by MailChimp!

Our latest tweets

Published by

Published by

.

Our community